Drinks Similar To Butter Baby

• Carrot Cake Shots

   drink recipe by: halo
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Carrot Cake

   drink recipe by: Chocolate Bunny
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Buttershots
  • Cinnamon
  • Hot Damn
  • Cream
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Johns Breast Milk

   drink recipe by: Alanna
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Kahlua
  • Ice
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Butterscotch Pudding Shot

  Ingredients:

  • Sugar
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Jello Pudding Shooter

   drink recipe by: Teresa
  

  Ingredients:

  • Vodka
  • Balieys
  • Vanilla Vodka

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Dairy Fire

   drink recipe by: Brady Hastings
  

  Ingredients:

  • Cuervo Tequila
  • Balieys
  • Tabasco

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Liquid 8 Ball

  Ingredients:

  • Rum
  • Balieys
  • Jagermeister
  • Rumple Minze

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Nuts N Berries

   drink recipe by: Wes Norton
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Chambord
  • Frangelico

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Where Did I Park My Car?

   drink recipe by: P.J.'s Lounge
  

  Ingredients:

  • Rum
  • Balieys
  • Jagermeister
  • Buttershots
  • Frangelico
  • Rumple Minze
  • Aftershock

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Liquid Cocaine

   drink recipe by: Justin Fitch
  

  Ingredients:

  • Water
  • Jagermeister
  • Cinnamon
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Godfather

   drink recipe by: AlexGreen
  

  Ingredients:

  • Amaretto
  • Ice
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Nuts And Berries

   drink recipe by: TBone
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Half And Half
  • Chambord
  • Ice
  • Cream
  • Frangelico

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Cheese Cake

   drink recipe by: Nelbuds Bar Florence Wisconsin
  

  Ingredients:

  • Pineapple Juice
  • Grenadine
  • Balieys
  • Ice
  • Dr. Pepper
  • Apple Juice
  • Pineapple

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Madame Butterfly

   drink recipe by: Melissa
  

  Ingredients:

  • Vodka
  • Balieys
  • Kahlua

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Cowboy Cocksuker

   drink recipe by: P.J.s Lounge
  

  Ingredients:

  • Beer
  • Balieys
  • Southern Comfort

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Light My Fire

   drink recipe by: Courtesy of my fave bartender Adam
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Kahlua

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Wet Pussy 3

  Ingredients:

  • Tequila
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Creamy Stiffy

   drink recipe by: Ellie
  

  Ingredients:

  • Vodka
  • Balieys
  • Coke
  • Buttershots
  • Ice
  • Gin
  • Cream

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Banana Dream

   drink recipe by: Jessica Bungay
  

  Ingredients:

  • Vodka
  • Balieys
  • Vanilla Vodka
  • Half And Half
  • Amaretto
  • Cream
  • Stoli

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Cherry Cheesecake

   drink recipe by: Linda
  

  Ingredients:

  • Cranberry Juice
  • Malibu Rum
  • Ice
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Moose Cum

   drink recipe by: Tom G.
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Kahlua
  • Jagermeister

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Bloody Nut Sack

   drink recipe by: patrick
  

  Ingredients:

  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Tornado

   drink recipe by: Gina
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Cream

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Train Wreck

   drink recipe by: Drink Doctor 34
  

  Ingredients:

  • Balieys
  • Jagermeister
  • Goldschlagger
  • Rumple Minze
  • Bailey's Irish Cream

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Rob Roy

   drink recipe by: Blaine
  

  Ingredients:

  • Vermouth
  • Ice
  • Scotch

  
  
   See Entire Recipe
  

• Previous
• More drinks